Talk:Stephen Clay (Michael Easton)/@comment-3418856-20130110211801/@comment-3418856-20130204053549

I think it boils down to trying to keep the two shows in the same universe and continuity. When Lucy came back to town, she should have recognized John and Sam as Caleb and Livvie because she was a big part of PC and they look exactly the same. Caleb first disguised himself as a priest when he came to town. When he came back the second time, he was disguised as a rock star. So, in Lucy's mind, it makes perfect sense for him to be disguised as a cop. What I don't get though is why Lucy just took Felicia's word that Duke wasn't Joshua. I don't get why she just was like "oh, okay, he's not Joshua" when Felicia told her. I'd think she'd be adamant about him too.